Monday, 7 November 2016

An anti-Thatcher Conservative and his life in politics



Sir Julian Critchley MP
(1931 - 2000)

‘A Bag of Boiled Sweets’ - the only safe pleasure for a politician – is the title of the memoirs of Julian (later Sir Julian) Critchley MP. The former Conservative member for Aldershot was a prominent opponent of Margaret Thatcher and once described her as the ‘great she-elephant’. As the famous prime minister was on the rise, her party was in decline, Critchley once wrote. It is clear he was never going to have a role in her government – but this didn’t bother him too much. The backbenches were his habitat and it was from this position that the Europhile MP operated. He was a constituency MP as well as regularly writing articles for newspapers and his talent for the written word is obvious once you start turning the pages of this charming book.

Growing up in the 1980’s, I was acutely aware of the harshness of Mrs Thatcher and her government. It was hard for me to bring myself to feel anything but antipathy for ‘the grocer’s daughter’. My late maternal grandmother – a staunch Fine Gael supporter – was an ardent admirer of Britain’s first female prime minister – probably one of the few matters of disagreement between the two of us. During her time in office (1979-90) I rather ignorantly assumed that the only people who disliked Mrs Thatcher lay outside the Conservative and Unionist Party. How wrong I was!

Julian Critchley's was one of the few voices, within the Tory ranks, that refused to be silenced in opposition to the authority of Mrs Thatcher. He grew up in Shropshire during the 1930’s and 1940’s, living through World War II while at school. After attending public school he went on to spend time in Paris and became a lover of that city and its lifestyle. He even was involved, at one point, in the establishment of a Young Conservative Club in the French capital. Critchley married three times during his lifetime, yet he comes across as a gentleman. One suspects he may not have been entirely comfortable around gay people – but that is probably due to the era in which he lived through more than any great prejudice. There is no evidence to suggest the author was anything other than a caring, decent man – but one who enjoyed life’s finer past times nevertheless.

He first entered the House of Commons in 1959 representing the constituency of Rochester and Chatham. Following a period in the political wilderness – due to electoral defeat – he returned to the mother of all parliaments in 1970, for the safe Tory seat of Aldershot. He fought every subsequent general election until his retirement at the 1992 general election which saw John Major’s government unexpectedly returned to office. Critchley suffered from polio in childhood yet managed to overcome this problem to live an almost trouble free life for decades before it returned with a vengeance when he was in his 60’s, sadly rendering him disabled and leaving him in terrible pain. However, for many years he’d got used to living the good life drinking fine wines and dining well. All this high living contributed to his waistline – the perennial hazard of a life in politics – but it didn’t diminish his enthusiasm for life.

Towards the end of the book we are reminded of the events of November 1990 in which Mrs Thatcher spectacularly lost the leadership of her own party and with that her premiership. There then followed a witch hunt by pro-Thatcher Tories in which attempts were made to de-select some of the MP’s who had plotted against her. Critchley was one of those MP’s. Although efforts were made to have him de-selected, his local Conservative Association in Aldershot gave him the benefit of the doubt and stood by him. All attempts to remove him were thwarted and Critchley managed to see off his enemies. However as time went on the Conservatives became more and more right wing – despite Mrs Thatcher’s departure from front line politics. Anti-European sentiment had taken root and this would eventually lead to Critchley leaving the party that he had spent his life supporting. This larger-than-life figure, who was a friend and political ally of Michael Heseltine (he once wrote a biography on the Conservative grandee who is now aged 83), could never tolerate the ideological direction many of his colleagues were travelling in. He went on to be a vocal critic of William Hague’s leadership when the Yorkshire man succeeded John Major in 1997.

Julian Critchley eventually left his second wife as their relationship gradually became more strained. In the early 1990’s he began a relationship with Prue Marshall, who he had known in the 1960’s. Romance didn’t blossom then, but this time was different. The relationship worked out and the couple were together until his death in the year 2000 at the age of 69. This book, written in 1995, is a fitting tribute to a fascinating political figure who – although never assuming high office – entertained many with his witty observations. One wonders what he would make of ‘Brexit’ and the state of the Conservative Party today. He’s perhaps safer in his grave, no longer suffering the stresses of political life. Anyone with an interest in British politics during the latter half of the 20th century should seek out this book. It is an entertaining and stimulating read from start to finish.


  • 'A Bag of Boiled Sweets' by Julian Critchley (Faber & Faber, 1995)


Sunday, 23 October 2016

Mr Kenny is living on borrowed time




Photo: Newstalk
As a young boy I can remember sitting in the kitchen while my mother listened to Gay Byrne on the radio. Often a caller would come on the line and overstay their welcome – singing a long song or getting into a complicated story with no obvious ending. In such circumstances Gay’s manner turned businesslike. “Good day to you now” was how the Late Late Show presenter usually terminated such a discussion. It was a reminder that no one should ever dare try to put Ireland’s most popular broadcaster off his stride when he was on a roll.

Like the talkative radio caller, someone else who looks like overstaying his welcome is our present taoiseach. Enda Kenny has taken Fine Gael a long way since the party’s grim general election result in 2002 but no leader can realistically expect to last for more than 15 years in modern politics. Next year Mr Kenny will reach this milestone and speculation in the media is growing, by the day, over his future in politics.

Fine Gael are spoilt for choice at the moment as they have at least two first rate candidates in their ranks to replace Mr Kenny, whenever he decides to leave (or if he is deposed in a power struggle). Leo Varadkar is a very popular young politician in party circles and is a polished media performer (indeed, like Gay Byrne, it’s hard to stop him when he gets going). If, for whatever reason, the Minister for Social Protection fails to ascend to the leadership, another big name immediately springs to mind.

Simon Coveney, currently our Minister for Housing (among other responsibilities), is a safe pair of hands and equally as popular with his colleagues as Mr Varadkar. He is less smooth in style, yet remains a formidable force to be reckoned with. A possible compromise candidate, if one were needed could be Frances Fitzgerald.  She is a deeply conservative politician and less popular than the other two aforementioned gentlemen.

I’ve been observing the political scene and it seems that Ms Fitzgerald is keeping her cards close to her chest. For now she is staying loyal to the taoiseach. It is possible – similar to Theresa May’s appointment as British prime minister earlier this year – that the Minister for Justice might find herself in the top spot if Messrs Varadkar and Coveney falter in the race to succeed Mr Kenny. That scenario is unlikely to develop, but at this time cannot be ruled out as a possibility.

We have examined the possible successors to Mr Kenny. But before a successor emerges there first needs to be a vacancy. That means the Mayo TD must make up his mind quickly about his political intentions. Like the irritating caller on Gay Byrne’s radio programme, Mr Kenny, it seems, is not getting the message. Politically speaking, he is living on borrowed time and the longer he stays on the more damage he will cause – to his legacy, his party and ultimately the country.

Next month is the 26th anniversary of a momentous event in political history. In November 1990 Mrs Thatcher - once an indomitable force in world politics – lost the leadership of her party. Soon after this painful humiliation she ceased to be Britain’s prime minister. If he wants to avoid the same fate, Mr Kenny will have to set out a plan – albeit privately – to step down. In politics, as in life, time comes for everyone. His time is nearly up and there is no point in him thinking he is invincible. Reality will bite eventually whether he likes it or not.

Sunday, 25 September 2016

Another interesting twist in British politics

Mr Corbyn has been sensationally re-elected leader of the Labour Party at this year's Party Conference in Liverpool. The article below was originally written in September 2015 and published in THE FAT DUBLINER,  following last year's leadership election.

Photo: BBC


Last weekend Jeremy Corbyn (pictured above) was elected the new leader of the British Labour party. He beat off three Labour MP’s – Andy Burnham, Yvette Cooper and Liz Kendall – despite being a rank outsider when the leadership campaign began in June. His challengers were considered part of the ‘mainstream’ Labour party while he, in sharp contrast, has spent his entire political career (32 years) on the backbenches.

The outcome of the leadership battle sees Corbyn turning from poacher to gamekeeper. For years he has been a thorn in the side of the establishment unlike Blair and Brown, who were happy to move Labour in a more right wing direction. The new leader will now face British Prime Minister David Cameron and the former will have to rise to the challenge. It is a challenge not only for him personally but also for the Labour party, many of whom oppose his political views.

Since the leadership result was announced, a succession of Labour MP’s have resigned from the shadow cabinet. This makes Corbyn’s job considerably more difficult to conduct. But what took the MP for Islington North to the top so soon and how has this new scenario emerged? What follows is an attempt at answering that question.

To get a better understanding of the Corbyn victory we have to go back thirty years to 1985. Neil Kinnock was the Labour party leader at the time. At the party’s conference, held that year in Bournemouth, the Welshman made a speech in which he ferociously attacked the hard left. Labour’s radical fringe had been flexing their political muscles ever since Mrs Thatcher came to office six years previously.

Kinnock laid much of the groundwork for his successors. If he hadn’t hit out at the ‘militant tendency’ within the party, it is quite possible that he would not have been able to impose the discipline needed for Labour to effectively oppose the then Conservative government (this is despite the fact that they were unable to win a general election until 1997).

During the 1980’s the main opposition party was entrenched in a battle between ideology and pragmatism. The latter form of political strategy won out over the former and this ultimately returned Labour to government once again. However since the New Labour project ended, following Gordon Brown’s defeat at the 2010 general election, the balance has shifted in favour of a more ideological position. This may help to explain why the Corbynites are now in the ascendency.

Corbyn – rightly or wrongly – appeals to a much smaller section of British voters than Cameron. Despite the strong endorsement, last week, by the Labour party membership, the new leader is in a minority among opposition MP’s. The journalist Matthew Parris recently spoke on Channel 4 News. He made the point that the Corbyn issue could become a recurring problem for Labour with conflict between the party’s MP’s and the wider membership. Indeed some say that the new leader may only last a matter of weeks in the job.

Whatever way one looks at this, it is clear that Corbyn was democratically elected and must therefore be taken seriously. The Labour party now has a leader of real principle and that cannot really have been said of the organisation’s most recent leaders. The party's leadership have for too long neglected core ideology and this has positioned them closer to the Conservatives than ever before. Now the ideological wing have their man in the top spot as Westminster politics takes another interesting twist. This battle isn’t over yet.

Friday, 15 July 2016

Conservative right wing benefits from Mr Cameron’s demise




An awful lot has happened in British politics over the course of the last month. A new prime minister has been installed at Number 10 Downing Street leading what seems like the most right-wing government since the Thatcher era. Theresa May, we are told, is a no nonsense politician. She will have to pick up the pieces left by her predecessor following Britain’s vote to leave the European Union.

The ‘Brexit’ vote will be David Cameron’s lasting political legacy. His decision to hold a referendum on the UK’s membership of the EU has obscured his earlier achievements. When he became leader of the Conservative and Unionist Party in 2005 he set about re-branding the organisation. Out went the old torch logo to be replaced by a new green and blue design. Mr Cameron was seen on a sledge with huskies on a visit to Lapland further underlining his supposed green credentials.

I can recall the final showdown between himself and David Davis (now part of Mrs. May’s newly formed government) during the leadership contest. Essentially it was a battle between the traditional wing of the party and Mr Cameron’s new, more progressive supporters. The ‘nasty party’ was to be reformed almost like ‘New Labour’ under Tony Blair. The Tories would reach out to those they had previously ignored. For awhile I genuinely thought Mr Cameron could radically change his party for the better. But despite going into coalition with the Liberal Democrats, supporting gay marriage and standing up for the disabled, he ultimately failed to resolve the big problem which has beset the Conservatives for decades – Europe.

It is said of political leaders that they ‘campaign in poetry and govern in prose’. This is no less true of Mr Cameron. His ‘Achilles heel’ was the ‘Brexit’ referendum and calling it was his big mistake. It has cost him his political career barely 12 months since, unexpectedly, winning a general election (the first Conservative leader to do so for almost a quarter of a century). All this is common knowledge now, with acres of news print devoted to the aftermath of this incredible referendum. The MP for Whitney has now departed and left Mrs. May to deal with the political fallout. She has assembled a right-wing government with figures like Mr Davis, Boris Johnson and Liam Fox in key positions at cabinet. Far from curbing the harshness of his party, Mr Cameron has, through holding the recent referendum, freed the radicals among his colleagues.

Over the course of the last 40 years, or so, prime ministers have met their demise in various ways. James Callaghan had ‘the winter of discontent’; Margaret Thatcher had the poll tax; John Major had ‘Black Wednesday’; Tony Blair had the Iraq war; Gordon Brown had the banking crisis and now Mr Cameron has succumbed to Euro-phobia.  God only knows what troubles are in store for Mrs. May. The post of prime minister is a poison chalice and she will have to tread carefully. At this time it is crucial that a strong opposition is gathered otherwise this newly emboldened government of the right (for that is what it is) could alienate more people than her predecessors did. The Conservative right have been let loose and they must be held to account.


Saturday, 11 June 2016

Brexit or no Brexit?

The referendum campaign, to decide whether or not the UK should leave the European Union, is nearing its climax. Voters will have their say and it will then be up to the politicians to implement the wishes of the majority. The main attraction to voting Leave would seem to be largely emotional. Unlike the Scottish independence referendum this campaign, in my view, is based far more on emotion. In the case of Scotland the economic arguments won out in the end. Who wants greater unemployment and a weak currency arrangement? The Scots made their decision based on cold facts . The emotional feelings of nationalism were cast aside.

Immigration, Nigel Farage tells us, is the single biggest issue facing Britain today. A growing security threat, due to the EU’s open borders policy, is also talked about by the Leavers. On the economic front, they say, Britain’s future will be far better outside the control of the bureaucrats in Brussels. The UK is a proud country. It boasts a strong multi ethnic society. Yet growing immigration has made some feel the situation has become a problem, a problem which can only be solved by leaving the EU.

It is true that Britain is one of the most prosperous nations on earth. Leaving the EU may not be a bad idea (for Britain at least) if they were part of an alternative network of trading nations, outside the EU. However this network has not yet been established and it is hard to imagine it ever being established. Leaving the EU now would be like someone walking out of a secure job with no alternative employment lined up. A ‘Brexit’, which looks increasingly likely at time of writing, could lead to greater economic risk. In addition there is only so much a democratic country can do to stem immigration levels.

On EU bureaucracy Mr Farage, Boris Johnson MP, Michael Gove MP, Priti Patel MP, Chris Grayling MP and other prominent Leavers, may have a point. The EU is too political in nature (largely to form a bulwark against Russian expansion in Eastern Europe) with too many member states than is necessary. Forming a consensus between all member states must be a real problem for those in charge. Reform is badly needed if the EU’s reputation is to be salvaged. If the British vote to leave this club of nations then the over politicisation of the organisation will be to blame.

Turning to Northern Ireland, visited recently by former Prime Ministers John Major and Tony Blair. At first I was amazed at the decision of the DUP to support a ‘Brexit’. How on earth do they sell this to the large – mainly Unionist voting – farming community, I asked myself? Surely if Britain leaves the EU this would mean farmers would no longer receive subsidies. In such circumstances Arlene Foster would have to go cap in hand to the Treasury in London to make up the shortfall. At present funding to the NI executive is being cut by the central government at Westminster. It is hard to see how the province can benefit economically from Britain leaving the EU. The emotional factor plays well with Unionists but wrapping oneself in the Union Jack won’t stop an economic slump, which would be the likely outcome – at least in the short term – of a ‘Brexit’. Again there is much that needs to change in relation to the EU but separating from that group of trading nations would be akin to throwing the baby out with the water, a serious – unnecessary – risk.

On the Remain side the most credible argument for staying is economic. If it weren’t for that it is likely there would be no referendum held on this issue. The matter would’ve been decided long ago. As I write, the Leave campaign has received a boost in the polls. This puts them ahead of the Remain side (55% to 45%). If this is a true representation of voters’ intentions then it may be that the issue of immigration has greater traction with the public than economics. The latter is a more abstract subject for people to get to grips with than the former. By contrast, immigration is understood better by the ordinary man/woman out on the street. The economy is a more long term consideration, but no less important. The benefits to the UK of staying inside the EU are considerable. These benefits will probably only be fully realised if a ‘Brexit’ is triggered on the 23 June. It is important for voters to keep this in mind as Polling Day approaches.

Saturday, 14 May 2016

Bleak future now beckons for Labour







Coming shortly after Saint Valentine’s Day, this year’s general election didn’t bring much love to the Labour Party. Their deep throated embrace of Fine Gael – their partners in coalition government since 2011 – could well prove to be the kiss of death for a political organisation founded on left wing principles. These principles were – and continue to be – largely ignored by the party’s Dail contingent and it’s hard to see what sort of future Labour now has as a political force.

Could Alan Kelly – assuming he succeeds Joan Burton (not certain as I write) – be the last leader of Ireland’s Labour Party? Mr Kelly is known to be one of the chief advocates of the water charges that have caused so much controversy. The charge is an anathema to many on the left of Irish politics and the party’s support for this, in addition to stubbornly backing up Fine Gael in government on other issues, has alienated many Labour voters.

Before Polling Day Labour boasted 37 TD’s in Dail Eireann. Now their numbers barely reach seven deputies. This electoral disaster didn’t occur by accident. Similar to the Labour Party in Britain, the Irish Labour Party has abandoned its original principles. This became clear over the course of the last five years as they worked closely on economic regeneration, in partnership with Fine Gael, a party which has little sympathy for those on the thin end of the wedge. By allying themselves to the architects of austerity, Labour have been left dangerously exposed.

Only two of Labour’s seven TD’s represent Dublin constituencies. This compares with 18 Dublin TD’s before February’s election. It is hard to see them reaching this figure again. Labour hemorrhaged votes all over the place. Outside of Dublin the chief beneficiaries were the Independents, Sinn Fein and Fianna Fail. In the capital these parties took votes from Labour in addition to the Anti Austerity Alliance/People Before Profit and other smaller left wing groups who have benefited from huge disaffection among Labour voters.

Despite the Labour Party being in an extremely vulnerable position, it still remains strong as a national organisation. But that may not be for long. The future for the party will depend on whether or not the membership, rather than the leadership, can define Labour’s political identity and take it back to its left wing roots, where the party’s true support lies. Unless this happens Ireland’s Labour Party could well be extinct in a few short years. They are heading for political oblivion.

Mr Kelly’s stout defence of the water charges flies in the face of many on the left of Irish politics. This has done much damage to Labour’s reputation among the voters. By failing to assert themselves in government they have allowed themselves to be portrayed as no longer being a friend to the disadvantaged in Irish society. Much will have to be done to repair the damage and it is unclear at this stage what, if anything, can be done to stem the tide. The lesson to all political parties must be: if you ignore your voters, they will ignore you. This is precisely what has happened to the Irish Labour Party. James Connolly must be turning in his grave.

Friday, 6 May 2016

A government at last

Government Buildings, Merrion Street, Dublin.

We are at the end of the beginning. More than two months have passed since the general election and a government now looks to be in the final stages of being formed. A Fine Gael minority administration was always the most likely outcome. The main surprise has been the length of time our politicians have taken to reach this point.

Fianna Fail, initially, displayed a collective arrogance in their refusal to enter government with Fine Gael. They obstinately stood their ground as Enda Kenny tried his best to coax them into his arms. Instead they rebuffed his advances and it became clear a grand coalition was not on the cards. Micheal Martin’s party has instead managed to force concessions from Fine Gael, thus weakening Mr Kenny’s hand. Fianna Fail have since agreed to give confidence and supply to a Fine Gael minority government provided the larger party can achieve sufficient backing among independent TD’s.

Having, more or less, satisfied the demands of Fianna Fail, the next task for Fine Gael negotiators was to get agreement with the independent deputies, to vote for Mr Kenny as Taoiseach. As I write talks have not yet concluded but the money is on a government being put together in the next few days.

The new ‘third force’ in Irish politics, Sinn Fein, are, meanwhile, content to stay out of government. The republicans feel they will magically rise in support, like yeast in an oven, with the voters and this will take them into a majority government on their own. But Gerry Adams and his followers won’t have it as easy as in Northern Ireland where they have been in government for a number of years now. In the Republic they cannot expect the same levels of popularity. However they will no doubt serve in government in the future, once Mr Adams has left the scene.

We have examined the events leading up to the present situation. What of the next three or more years? Mr Kenny has been accused of arrogance by some, particularly over his stewardship of the previous government. For this next period in office he will, however, have to be a lot less strident. His room for manoeuvre has been seriously restricted as a result of February’s general election and arrogance will not be tolerated by the independent deputies sitting around the cabinet table.

The new arrangement will, more than likely, cause great frustration to the Fine Gael leader and his senior colleagues. They will have to move more slowly and spend more time negotiating policy differences. That is the price to be paid for perceived political arrogance and we will all be the better for that. After the circus of the last couple of months it now seems that, at last, the dust has settled. The Irish people are about to get a government and there’s plenty of work for that government to do. The time for talking is over and the time for action is nigh.

Monday, 29 February 2016

Soldiers of Destiny have broader support than former Blue Shirts



Irish general elections rarely lead to one-party governments being formed. On the contrary, coalitions nearly always emerge once the seats are allocated. The 32nd Dail will be no different. The dominance of Fianna Fail has been eroded since the party's devastation at the 2011 general election. In 2016 three political factions will share most of the seats: Fine Gael, Fianna Fail and Sinn Fein.  The rest of the seats will be held by independents, Labour, the Green Party and the hard left People Before Profit/Anti Austerity Alliance.


As yet no one party has a clear majority. The most likely outcome will be some sort of arrangement between Fine Gael and Fianna Fail. If this doesn't happen then we are in for what could be a long period of political instability.  But why should these two civil war parties join together now? The answer is that they are the only ones who can provide a stable government. It is hard to see both parties participating in a coalition government together, however some kind of deal could quite realistically be arrived at.

The most likely scenario is that Fine Gael (the largest party) will form a minority administration with Fianna Fail support, but without the latter party formally entering government. This would allow Micheal Martin and his colleagues to continue to rebuild their organisation without receiving the sort of flack that has so badly damaged both Fine Gael and Labour in this year's poll.

By staying out of government, this time, Fianna Fail may be able to block attempts by Sinn Fein to become the main party of opposition. So all round the best option would seem to be a Fine Gael minority government backed by Fianna Fail. The only other viable alternative is to hold another general election and nobody wants that right now.

Many say that Fianna Fail are a conservative party. This is only partly true. Like Fine Gael, they attract plenty of support among middle class voters. However the Soldiers of Destiny have a much broader appeal than the former Blue Shirts. The party of De Valera and Lemass have been in office more often than any other party in Irish politics. At the 2011 general election they lost a huge amount of goodwill with the public. This year they have clawed back a considerable number of seats and it is highly likely they will be back in government in the not too distant future. Until then they must continue to rebuild the trust they threw away under Brian Cowen's disastrous leadership.

The workings of the 32nd Dail will be fascinating to witness as efforts begin on forming a government. In the coming weeks we will see if Irish politicians can put aside their petty differences and work in the national interest, or whether they prefer to continue the tribalism that has held us back for so long.

Saturday, 20 February 2016

The changing face of Sinn Fein

Photo: Pacemaker/BBC

Like him or dislike him, Gerry Adams remains the most charismatic figure in modern Irish politics. His support for ‘the armed struggle’ in Northern Ireland has brought him enemies, yet some still see him as statesmanlike. However could his time in the sun be about to end? The recent general election campaign has seen him face challenging questions on his competence over Sinn Fein’s taxation policies as well as his close association with the IRA. While most people have made up their minds on how they feel about the Sinn Fein leader, his ability to attract support for his party, particularly in the Republic, may no longer be as potent.


Adams has led Sinn Fein since the 1980’s and all the other political leaders – in Belfast, London and Dublin – from that time are either dead or now retired. Is it time the republican leader stepped off the political stage? This is very unlikely to happen, in the short term at least. He is held in high esteem by the Sinn Fein membership with virtually 100 per cent obedience (there have been rare exceptions such as Peadar Toibin’s dissent on the abortion issue).



So it seems unlikely that there will be a new Sinn Fein leader for some time. However if, for whatever reason, a vacancy emerges it is highly likely to be filled by Dubliner, Mary Lou McDonald. Currently the party’s deputy leader, McDonald is known for her pragmatism and would be a popular successor in contrast to Adams’ more ideological style. If this scenario materialises it could have the effect of broadening Sinn Fein’s support in the Republic.



Adams is the glue that has for so long bound Sinn Fein together as a political force. They are the only political party that campaign on an all-Ireland basis. But since the setting up of the Northern Ireland executive Sinn Fein have become split into two departments – Martin McGuinness taking charge of the Northern operation with Adams leading the party’s Dail contingent.



The leadership had calculated that the party would take power in Northern Ireland, while at the same time entering government in the Republic. Adams moved his base from West Belfast to Louth and this would swiftly lead to a united Ireland. This was a gamble and it looks like their calculation is not going to pay off. Far from unifying, it looks like Sinn Fein has been weakened. The question is if McDonald becomes leader, will Sinn Fein continue to diverge? If this happens the rank and file’s dream of a united Ireland could be as far away as ever.